Tools

PTE Election vs Composite Return vs Traditional Withholding: Which Path Is Right for Your Business?

Nov 28, 2025

Sleek office desk with a laptop showing a digital tax chart, folders labeled “PTE Election,” “Composite Return,” and “Withholding,” with a calculator and financial papers nearby.

If you run a pass-through business, you’ve probably seen phrases like PTE election, composite return, or nonresident withholding pop up. Each one sounds technical, but they all answer a simple question.

Who pays the state income tax on your business profits and how is it reported?
States give partnerships and S corporations a few different ways to handle taxes for resident and nonresident owners. The problem is that each option comes with different rules, cash-flow effects, administrative work, and tax outcomes. The wrong choice can lead to extra filings, missed deductions, or owners paying more than they need to.

This guide is here to cut through that confusion. By the end, you’ll know:

• What a PTE election, composite return, and traditional withholding actually do
• How they affect owners differently
• How to choose the best path for your setup

Let’s get started!

What Is a PTE Election?

Close-up of a ledger with entity-level tax calculations, alongside a calculator, pen, and digital tax software on a desk, softly lit.

A PTE election lets the business pay tax at the entity level instead of forcing owners to report their share of income on their personal state returns. More than 30 states now offer this option, mostly as a workaround to the federal SALT deduction cap.

How it works

• Your entity elects into the state’s PTE tax for the year (usually annual and irrevocable).
• The business pays state income tax on taxable income.
• Owners get a credit or income adjustment on their state return.
• Because the tax is paid by the business, it becomes a federal business deduction, avoiding the $10,000 SALT cap.

Key benefits

• Helps owners deduct more state taxes at the federal level.
• Simplifies nonresident filings in many states.
• Reduces or eliminates the need for traditional withholding in some jurisdictions.

Drawbacks

• Complex rules and inconsistent state guidance.
• Election deadlines vary.
• Not always beneficial for owners living in states that don’t recognize the credit.
• Does not apply to C-Corp owners.

If you want to know more about this, check out our full guide about PTE Election.

What Is a Composite Return?

Group of documents being merged into a central folder on a desk, symbolizing multiple nonresident owners’ taxes filed together under soft natural lighting.

A composite return is a group return filed by the entity for nonresident owners. Instead of each nonresident filing their own state tax return, the business files one combined return and pays their share of tax.

How it works

• Nonresident owners opt in to join the composite return.
• The entity calculates and pays tax for all participating owners.
• Those owners usually avoid filing an individual state return.
• Individual state-level deductions may be limited.

Key benefits

• Saves time for nonresident owners.
• Reduces administrative burden for the business in states that require separate withholding.
• Helps owners avoid multiple state tax filings.

Drawbacks

• Not available for every entity type in every state.
• Owners lose some personal deductions and credits.
• Composite tax is often calculated at the highest individual rate.

What Is Traditional Withholding for PTEs?

Business office illustration showing tax calculations for nonresident owners, with small ledgers and digital screens displaying estimated payments.

Traditional withholding is the default method in many states. When a pass-through entity has nonresident owners, the business must withhold estimated state taxes on behalf of those owners and remit them to the state.

How it works

• The business withholds and pays estimated state tax on behalf of nonresident owners.
• The owners file individual state returns and claim credits for the withheld tax.
• The entity continues withholding throughout the year.

Key benefits

• Works in every state that requires nonresident compliance.
• Straightforward when only one or two nonresident owners exist.
• Does not require elections or consent.

Drawbacks

• Nonresident owners must file their own returns.
• Creates extra administrative steps.
• Does not offer SALT deduction relief.
• May overlap with PTE tax obligations depending on state rules.

Side-by-Side Comparison

This table shows the most important differences.

Feature	PTE Election	Composite Return	Traditional Withholding
Who Pays the Tax?	The entity	The entity for consenting nonresidents	The individual owners
Federal SALT Deduction Benefit?	Yes	No	No
Nonresident Compliance Relief?	Often yes	Yes	No
Requires Owner Participation?	No, entity-level	Yes, each owner opts in	No
Tax Rate Applied	Entity rate	Often highest personal rate	Individual rate
Administrative Complexity	Medium to high	Medium	Low to medium
Best Use Case	Maximize federal SALT deductions	Simplify nonresident filings	States where other options aren't available

How to Choose the Right Option for Your Business

Accountant reviewing multiple spreadsheets and colorful charts spread across a wide desk, visually comparing and analyzing options.

Now that you understand the three approaches, here’s how to decide which one fits your business. Since we removed the separate “when to choose” sections, all decision-making guidance is consolidated here.

Step 1. Look at your owners’ residency

• Many nonresident owners? Composite returns may build simplicity.
• Only one or two nonresidents? Traditional withholding might be fine.
• Owners in states that give full PTE credits? PTE election becomes appealing.

Step 2. Check the SALT deduction impact

Ask one key question: “Would owners benefit from bypassing the federal SALT cap?”

If yes, a PTE election is often the strongest option.

If not, a composite return or withholding may be simpler.

Step 3. Review each owner’s home state rules

Some states:
• Do not recognize the PTE credit.
• Provide limited credits.
• Impose higher tax when using composite returns.

If an owner lives in a state that penalizes or limits the credit, composite or withholding may work better.

Step 4. Consider administrative workload

• PTE elections require annual elections, estimated payments, and complex calculations.
• Composite returns require collecting consent and managing multiple owner categories.
• Withholding is predictable but forces owners to file individually.

Choose the path that fits your team’s capacity.

Step 5. Estimate the total tax effect

This is where the dollars matter.

Model:
• Entity-level taxes
• Owner-level credits
• Out-of-state credits
• SALT deduction benefit
• Nonresident tax rates
• Administrative costs

The right answer often comes from comparing two or three scenarios.

Step 6. Combine methods when allowed

Some states allow:
• PTE election + composite return
• PTE election + withholding
• Composite return + withholding

Using more than one option can solve both compliance and deduction goals.

State-by-State Considerations

Professional using a tablet displaying a state-by-state tax comparison chart, with maps and documents spread across the desk.

Every state sets its own rules for PTE taxes, composite returns, and withholding. Here are the major differences to watch.

Election rules differ

• Some require elections by March 15.
• Some allow elections at the time of filing.
• Others only allow online elections.

Tax bases differ

• Some states tax only resident-owner income.
• Others tax all distributable income.
• Allocation and apportionment rules vary.

Credits differ

• Some states offer full dollar-for-dollar PTE credits.
• Some cap or reduce the credit.
• Some disregard the credit entirely.

Filing relief varies

• Some states waive nonresident returns for composite participants.
• Others still require separate filings for certain owners.

A tax professional can model these rules based on your actual states and owners.

Final Thoughts

Calm workspace with neatly stacked final tax documents, a laptop showing completed calculations, and warm natural light creating a professional yet relaxed atmosphere.

Choosing between a PTE election, composite return, and traditional withholding doesn’t have to be confusing. Once you understand the purpose of each option and how they impact owners, the right answer becomes clearer. Start with residency patterns, check the SALT deduction benefit, look at home-state recognition rules, and then model the numbers.

If you want personalized guidance or help running multi-state modeling, a tax professional can run the full comparison so you choose the path that saves time and tax dollars.

For an overview of how PTE elections work and which owners qualify, see our full guide on PTE Election and Nonresident Owners.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a PTE election always better than a composite return?

No. A PTE election is usually better when the SALT deduction benefit is meaningful, but a composite return often wins on simplicity.

Can I switch between options each year?

Most states require an annual election for PTE tax. Composite returns and withholding can change yearly as owners enter or leave the business.

Do all owners have to join a composite return?

No. Participation is voluntary. Nonparticipating owners must file their own returns.

Can a business use more than one method at the same time?

Yes, depending on the state. Some allow combining PTE elections with composite returns or withholding.

Does the PTE tax apply to S corporation wages or guaranteed payments?

Generally no. The PTE tax usually applies only to taxable distributive income.

Can a PTE election reduce state tax liability for resident owners?

Yes. While the main benefit is bypassing the federal SALT cap, some states allow credits or adjustments that also reduce state-level taxes for resident owners.

What happens if a nonresident owner doesn’t consent to a composite return?

The nonresident owner must file their own state return and pay any state taxes owed individually. The entity cannot include them in the composite.

Are PTE elections available in all states?

No. Only certain states, such as New York, California, and Illinois, currently offer PTE tax elections. Rules vary by state and eligibility.

Do composite returns or PTE elections affect federal income reporting?

The PTE election can affect federal taxes by creating a business-level deduction. Composite returns generally do not impact federal reporting, but withholding amounts are reflected on owners’ federal returns as credits.